In 2023, rePro-Truth reported on efforts of various U.S. anti-abortion activists to restrict the treatment of tubal ectopic pregnancies — inspired by El Salvador’s barbaric anti-abortion policies.
Frighteningly, some of these efforts go even further than the Salvadoran Model by calling for performing medical experimentation on patients with tubal ectopic pregnancies, without these patients’ consent. In 2019, for example, legislation was introduced in Ohio that would have subjected physicians treating patients with ectopic pregnancies to prosecution for “abortion murder” unless the physicians surgically attempted to re-implant the ectopic pregnancies into the uterus.
Recently, abortion foes have intensified their efforts to restrict treatment for tubal ectopic pregnancies, labeling ending these pregnancies as “murder.” In light of this, I am re-posting (below ⬇) a portion of rePro-Truth’s 2023 article.
Next week, I will be publishing a thorough fact check of the claims made by activists attempting to restrict treatment for tubal ectopic pregnancies, including an examination of the sources used in those claims. I will also be publishing a piece on why legally requiring doctors to perform re-implantation surgery is unethical — even if it successful re-implantation were possible.
The Salvadoran Model: Ectopic Pregnancy and Expectant Waiting
“The impact of conservative treatment [under El Salvador’s total abortion ban] is perhaps most readily observed in the way Salvadoran doctors treat [tubal] ectopic pregnancy.”1
Ectopic means "occurring in an abnormal position or in an unusual manner or form.”2 An ectopic pregnancy occurs when a fertilized egg implants in a place it shouldn’t. A tubal ectopic pregnancy, which is never viable, occurs when the fertilized egg implants in the fallopian tube. Fallopian tubes are very small and are not able to stretch to accommodate a growing embryo. Left untreated, a tubal ectopic pregnancy will result in the rupture of the pregnant person’s fallopian tube, causing massive internal bleeding. Hence, this type of ectopic pregnancy “is the most common cause of maternal mortality in the first trimester.”3
Tubal ectopic pregnancies “always requires treatment” (termination of pregnancy pre-viability).4 There are three treatment options.
Because El Salvador has banned all abortions (pre-viability terminations of pregnancy) without exception, “doctors treating these patients — some as young as nine — are forced to stand by and wait until the tube ruptures,” putting patients’ lives on the line.5 Only after a patient's fallopian tube has ruptured and internal hemorrhaging has commenced may Salvadoran doctors perform emergency surgery to save the patient.
Within the anti-abortion movement, this approach is thought of as “treatment”; in reality, these patients are receiving no ectopic pregnancy treatment at all.
Instead of treating ectopic pregnancies, doctors are treating ruptured fallopian tubes.
“There is no medical reason to wait: these fetuses will not survive. The law forces women to risk their lives for a pregnancy that will never become a child.”6
One Salvadoran doctor described, with evident frustration, the conservative “treatment” of ectopic pregnancies under the abortion ban in El Salvador.7 First, the patient is hospitalized. Next, according to the doctor:
“you watch her night and day with scans, and the minute it bursts, you operate and take the tube… She’s in imminent risk of dying and I’ve got the responsibility of saving her life. Waiting is totally contrary to medical principles. It’s no different from having an aneurism in the brain; once can see from scans that it’s growing and growing. Why would you wait until it explodes? There’s no single medical principle that would justify waiting.”8
Another doctor, working at a public maternity ward in El Salvador, lamented:
“Even though we know that we must intervene, we can’t because the embryo is still alive. So, we have to wait until the patient shows signs of haemorrhage, because otherwise it’s illegal. Some colleagues will note on ultrasound scans: ‘ectopic pregnancy: embryo alive’. Beneath that will be noted: ‘remember, it is illegal to do this’. And the patient is even more confused.”9
In a 2023 article at El Faro, an internationally acclaimed Salvadoran media outlet, Natasha Reifenberg and Jocelyn Viterna wrote, “To be clear, Salvadoran law has created a practice incompatible with ethical medicine. It demands that doctors let a pregnant woman die so that an embryo or fetus, which will inevitably die, expires inside the mother’s body, not outside it.”10
Bringing the Salvadoran experiment to American Soil
The anti-abortion movement in the United States is increasingly attempting to bring El Salvador’s ongoing, unregulated medical experimentation upon pregnant people, including children, to US maternal healthcare, including El Salvador’s dangerous, conservative treatment of tubal ectopic pregnancies.
For some years now, various U.S. abortion opponents, in attempting to move the Overton Window, have been spreading misinformation about tubal ectopic pregnancies and claiming that terminating these pregnancies is immoral.
In a 2019 article laden with misinformation, for example, Georgi Boorman recklessly told readers that there is only a small risk of exsanguinating from a ruptured fallopian tube left untreated, and deliriously claimed that a “[tubal] ectopic pregnancy can move on its own, reimplanting in a safer location and even result[] in a healthy birth.”11
Sure, you might bleed to death, she said, but is that really “enough to prompt you to suffer through purposely destroying your own child? Would you rather live with that on your conscience, knowing that in all likelihood it wasn’t necessary?”
TO BE CEAR: Guilt-tripping women into chancing death just because you don't like abortion is immoral ── and astoundingly cruel. Saving the lives of pregnant people is moral and good. The only way to suggest otherwise is if one’s sense of right and wrong has been systematically corrupted.
Abolitionists Rising - a group who wishes to completely abolish abortion in the US and prosecute abortion patients for homicide - published an error-riddled position piece (the author doesn’t seem to know that the cervix is part of the uterus, for example). The group’s position piece states that, when cardiac tones can be detected in a tubal ectopic embryo, neither a methotrexate injection, salpingostomy, or salpingectomy are morally permissible, because treating ectopic pregnancies will “cause the death of the baby.”12 In other words, abortion “abolitionists” intend to deny pregnant patients treatment for life-threatening tubal ectopic pregnancies even though these embryos will never survive.
This is the Salvadoran model: Instead of treating ectopic pregnancies, doctors treat ruptured fallopian tubes.
TO BE CEAR: A policy that conditions the provision of medical care upon evidence that a catastrophic organ rupture has occurred — be it a gallbladder or a spleen or a fallopian tube — necessitating immediate emergency surgery is wildly unethical.
Politically-mandated torture can not be justified. Politically-mandated organ loss can not be justified. No one should even be able to muster the gall to try.
In addition to “watchfully[] waiting" for a patient's internal organ to burst, Abolitionists Rising intends to legally require doctors to perform experimental surgery on patients with ectopic pregnancies to satiate abolitionists’ sadistic, dangerous, and futile attempt to “transplant [] the baby to the uterus“ (which is impossible).13
TO BE CLEAR: Ongoing, unregulated medical experimentation upon women and girls, without their consent, is wildly unethical.
Forcibly experimenting upon persons — treating them as one treats lab rats or gizmos and other contraptions — can not be justified. No one should even be able to muster the gall to try. Because women and girls are full persons.
“Pro-life Paradise”
El Salvador’s complete abortion ban “has resulted in the death and morbidity of thousands of women and girls and the loss of dignity for many more. The total ban on abortion in El Salvador is nothing less than institutionalized violence against women and a form of torture or other ill-treatment.” In its 2017 working visit to El Salvador, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) “observed that the abortion ban has ‘direct consequences on maternal morbidity and mortality rates.’” The Salvadoran government admits this truth. In El Salvador’s own report to the United Nations, the Salvadoran government “acknowledged that the total abortion ban is hampering further efforts to reduce maternal mortality and that reaching some of the targets is hindered due to ‘socio-cultural’ and economic factors, lack of access to contraceptives and prevalence of violence against women and girls.”
Despite this, powerful American anti-abortion groups continue to support El Salvador’s brutal abortion ban, including, but not limited to, the National Right to Life Committee, Human Life International, Heartbeat International and its media arm Pregnancy Help News, Americans United for Life, Lila Rose’s organization Live Action, and Alliance Defending Freedom, as well as the Catholic Church.
The human rights of all born persons “include the right to life, the right to be free from torture and other ill-treatment, the right to privacy, the right to health, the right to determine the number and spacing of children, the right to due process and the right to freedom from discrimination.”14 Unfortunately, these rights don’t exist for pregnant patients in “pro-life paradise.”
Oberman, M. (2018). Beatriz and Her Case. In Her Body, Our Laws: On the Front Lines of the Abortion War, from El Salvador to Oklahoma (pp. 29). essay, Beacon Press.
Merriam-Webster. (n.d.). Ectopic definition & meaning9-things-to-know-before-moving-to-nashville. Merriam-Webster. Retrieved January 11, 2023, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ectopic.
Creinin, M. (2023, June 4). 7 things to know about ectopic pregnancy. news. https://health.ucdavis.edu/news/headlines/7-things-to-know-about-ectopic-pregnancy/2022/05#:~:text=Ectopic%20pregnancy%20is%20the%20most,major%20internal%20bleeding%20and%20death
“Ectopic Pregnancy.” ACOG, https://www.acog.org/womens-health/faqs/ectopic-pregnancy.
Teter, C. (2020, March 1). When a miscarriage is a crime: El Salvador’s Humanitarian Crisis - Berkeley Political Review. Berkeley Political Review - UC Berkeley’s only nonpartisan political magazine. https://bpr.berkeley.edu/2020/01/19/when-a-miscarriage-is-a-crime-el-salvadors-humanitarian-crisis/
Teter, C. (2020, March 1). When a miscarriage is a crime: El Salvador’s Humanitarian Crisis - Berkeley Political Review. Berkeley Political Review - UC Berkeley’s only nonpartisan political magazine. https://bpr.berkeley.edu/2020/01/19/when-a-miscarriage-is-a-crime-el-salvadors-humanitarian-crisis/
Oberman, M. (2018). Beatriz and Her Case. In Her Body, Our Laws: On the Front Lines of the Abortion War, from El Salvador to Oklahoma (pp. 31). essay, Beacon Press.
El Salvador: On the brink of death: Violence against women and the abortion ban in El Salvador: Executive summary. Amnesty International. (2021, August 10). https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/amr29/004/2014/en/
El Salvador: On the brink of death: Violence against women and the abortion ban in El Salvador: Executive summary. Amnesty International. (2021, August 10). https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/amr29/004/2014/en/
Reifenberg, N., & Viterna, J. (2023, March 7). The Other Beatrices. The other beatrices. https://elfaro.net/en/202303/opinion/26755/The-Other-Beatrices.htm
North, A. (2019, September 11). This life-threatening pregnancy complication is the next frontier in the abortion debate. Vox. https://www.vox.com/2019/9/11/20859034/ectopic-pregnancy-abortion-federalist-intrauterine-ohio-surgery
Burkey, R. (2024, February 22). Examining ectopic pregnancy treatments from an abolitionist perspective - abolitionists rising. Abolitionists Rising - Abolish Abortion for the Glory of God. https://abolitionistsrising.com/examining-ectopic-pregnancy-treatments-from-an-abolitionist-perspective/
Burkey, R. (2024, February 22). Examining ectopic pregnancy treatments from an abolitionist perspective - abolitionists rising. Abolitionists Rising - Abolish Abortion for the Glory of God. https://abolitionistsrising.com/examining-ectopic-pregnancy-treatments-from-an-abolitionist-perspective/
El Salvador: On the brink of death: Violence against women and the abortion ban in El Salvador: Executive summary. Amnesty International. (2021, August 10). https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/amr29/004/2014/en/


1) im prolife and 2) im also realistic. those can go together.
also why the heck are girls pregnant at 9. that seems like a bigger issue.