Objectification is a particular form of dehumanization that involves seeing and/or treating a human being as an object. Scholars have identified at least TEN WAYS of treating persons as objects. THIS SERIES discusses each.
A patient awakes from laproscopic abdominal surgery and becomes alarmed to find her vulva and vaginal area sore. A nurse informs her that a medical student performed an unnecessary pelvic exam while she was under anesthesia and without her consent.
The same day, at a hospital in another state, a patient awakes from laproscopic abdominal surgery to discover his rectum sore and feeling bruised. Embarrased, he doesn't ask why. Medical staff never tell him that a medical student performed an unnecessary rectal exam on him while he was under anesthesia and without his consent.
***
A young woman at a maternity hospital in Dublin, Ireland, in labor with her child is wheeled into a medical theater filled with medical students. As the students look on, she is strapped down and her feet are strapped into stirrups. — No one informs her of what is about to happen to her.
The doctor delivering her baby picks up a “hacksaw, like a wood saw… a half-circle with a straight blade and a handle,” and he begins sawing through her pelvic bone. “Blood shoots up to the ceiling,” onto the doctor's glasses, and “all over the nurses.” Once the baby is delivered, the doctor sears the young woman with “something like a solder iron” to stop the bleeding.

Denial of Autonomy
The objectifier treats the object as lacking in autonomy and self-determination
Denial of Autonomy can occur in two ways:
non-attribution
violation

Each of the above are real events. Real things that happened to real people. Each is illustrative of the fact that, while medical care can be healing, it can also be a source of trauma, violation, violence, and, importantly, objectification.
When you see and treat a human being the way you see and treat an object - a mere thing - you are seeing and you are treating that human being in a way that is fundamentally inaccurate and inappropriate. — One of those fundamentally inaccurate and inappropriate ways of treating a fellow human being as a mere thing is to denying their autonomy.
AUTONOMY
(CAPACITY)
(a) an individual’s capacity for self-determination and self-governance
(b) an individual’s capacity for making self-determined decisions about one's own life, body, and future
AUTONOMY
(HUMAN RIGHTS)
the right to self-determination and self-sovereignty, including:
(a) DECISIONAL AUTONOMY
the right to make self-determined decisions about your own life, body, and future without coercion, force, violence, or undue interference
(b) BODILY AUTONOMY
the right to make self-determined decisions about what happens to and within your own body, without coercion, force, or violence
Denial of Autonomy can occur in two ways: non-attribution and violation. Consider what happened to each of the patients discussed above.
Non-consensual Pelvic Exams
There are various options for teaching medical students to perform pelvic exams: (1) practicing on medical mannequins; (2) practicing on paid volunteers; or (3) practicing on fully conscious patients who have given their explicit consent. Yet, the two hospital patients described above — along with millions of other Americans — were given non-consensual pelvic exams by medical students while these patients were under anesthesia.
Non-consensual pelvic exams are a significant violation of patients’ bodily integrity and informed consent that reflect a view of unconscious patients as inert, violable, and instrumental objects. Patients are seen and treated as if they are merely fleshy medical mannequins that can be used by others without their consent.
“While [non-consensual pelvic exams under anesthesia] are officially condemned as ‘unethical and unacceptable’ by both the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the Association of American Medical Colleges, medical institutions across the country have lobbied to prevent laws that require consent.”1 They argue that treating human beings like fleshy medical mannequins “not truly ethically reprehensible” because doing so “provides[] an irreplaceable learning experience.” They say that, if patients are allowed to decline to be used as fleshy medical mannequins prior to surgery, then “valuable learning opportunities would be forfeited.”2
Other defenders of non-consensual pelvic exams under anesthesia will “acknowledge that this long-standing practice can be morally and professionally problematic.”3 However, they also claim that legislative action requiring explicit patient consent “will detrimentally impact the regulative autonomy of medical organizations and hospitals.”4 Patient autonomy? Bad. Institutional autonomy? Good. Oh, the irony!
Denial of Autonomy is at the heart of both of these arguments.
Both fail to attribute to patients the rights to bodily and decisional autonomy — rights that belong to persons, but not objects. Both justify the physical violation of patients’ bodies under anesthesia, thus violating their autonomy. Hence, performing non-consensual pelvic exams on patients who are under anesthesia, as well as the arguments supporting this unethical practice, constitute Denial of Autonomy via non-attribution of autonomy and violation of autonomy.

Forced Symphysiotomy
The woman in labor discussed above was a victim of forced symphysiotomy — a procedure that involves sawing through a joint in the pelvic bone. The procedure, which results in lifelong disability, was used prior to medical advances increased the safety and survivability of cesarean sections.
In the 1940s, however, Catholic hospitals in Dublin, Ireland, revived the out-dated practice of performing symphysiotomies. Between 1944 and 1987, thousands of women were brutally subjected to forced symphysiotomies.
At these hospitals, religious ideology held more importance than patients’ safety and dignity.
Objectifying women as reproductive vessels, and holding to Catholic dogma classifying birth control is “intrinsically evil,” chose not to perform c-sections for fear that c-sections would limit the number of children women had and would encourage women to use birth control.
Sometimes, symphysiotomies were forcibly performed on women whose labor was not obstructed. In some of these cases, doctors brutalized these women for the sole purpose of increasing the numbers of children these women could have. In other cases, these women were tortured for the sole purpose of teaching medical students how to perform symphysiotomies.
“Powerful Catholic doctors who subscribed to the natural law viewed women, stereotypically, as vessels for procreation: nine or ten children was seen by them as the ideal family size. Proponents of symphysiotomy, such as [Dr. Arthur Barry], sectioned the pelvis of selected women to surgically ensure childbearing without limitation.”
United Nations
The decades of forced symphysiotomies in Ireland’s Catholic hospitals are a brutal example of Denial of Autonomy. Doctors saw their patients as inert breeding vessels and thus treated their patients as inert breeding vessels.
A vessel is not a person.
A vessel has no rights.
A vessel is only useful for one purpose.
The thousands of women who were needlessly mutilated — their bodies literally sawed through — were denied their right to to make self-determined decisions about what happens to and within your own body. Their autonomy was denied through violation in one of most barbaric ways imaginable.
For the Catholic doctors, each of these women was just a reproductive vessel. Why should anyone care how a vessel feels? ■
Seybold S. L. (2022). Not just "bodies with vaginas": A Kantian defense of pelvic exam consent laws. Bioethics, 36(9), 940–947. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13084
Seybold S. L. (2022). Not just “bodies with vaginas”: A Kantian defense of pelvic exam consent laws. Bioethics, 36(9), 940–947. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13084
Seybold S. L. (2022). Not just “bodies with vaginas”: A Kantian defense of pelvic exam consent laws. Bioethics, 36(9), 940–947. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13084
Seybold S. L. (2022). Not just “bodies with vaginas”: A Kantian defense of pelvic exam consent laws. Bioethics, 36(9), 940–947. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13084

